Fire Alarm -- Maintenance
The question isn't which one is more accurate. Most of the time, accuracy isn't needed. The question is which meter can be carried at all times, even when one can't foresee the immediate need?
Why Use a Cheap Meter when and Expensive Meter is Better?
By Douglas Krantz
Like a doctor always carrying a stethoscope, so should a technician always carry a multimeter.
Just in Case it's Needed
Just in case, the doctor carries the stethoscope around the neck; not thinking about it, it's always carried by the doctor. Likewise, just in case, the technician can carry the small multimeter in a belt pouch or pocket. Not thinking about it, it's just with the technician.
The doctor never knows when the stethoscope is going to be needed; the technician never knows when the multimeter is going to be needed. A stethoscope is a low tech test instrument; when compared to a high quality multimeter, a small inexpensive multimeter is a low tech test instrument.
To the doctor, a cardiograph machine is always available, but too big to carry when it's not needed. To the fire alarm service technician, a full function, highly accurate multimeter should always be available, but, being realistic, when it's not needed, it's just too cumbersome to carry everywhere.
A good multimeter is rugged, has all the possible functions needed at any time, and provides accuracy. But, besides the cost of the initial investment, there's another price to pay; it's too big to put in a pocket or a belt pouch. And much of the time, it's not needed, after a while it becomes just another cumbersome tool that can be left behind until needed.
Leaving the meter behind means, when the unforeseen need arises, the high quality multimeter might not be immediately available.
Small --- Not Accuracy is the Important Part
Small, of course, is the important part. It's not the accuracy, it's not the total number of functions, it's that the multimeter is with the technician. In a pocket or in a belt pouch, when the technician isn't carrying much more than a pocket screwdriver and multi-tool (like a Leatherman or Gerber), it's ready to be used.
Yes, having a good, high quality multimeter available to the technician will give the accurate measurements needed once in a while. But for most measurements, having any meter at all is far better than going back for the good multimeter.
Remember, maintenance/management people, the ones that are paying-by-the-hour to have you on site, are watching. Having tools with you that can be used without the down time of retrieval is what they're looking for.
Carry the Meter at All Times
Carrying the stethoscope at all times gives the doctor a good starting point for checking the status of the patients. For the few times more precision is needed to diagnose heart conditions, the cardiograph is available to the doctor.
Carrying an inexpensive meter at all times gives the technician a good starting point for checking the status of the fire alarm system. For the few times more precision is needed to troubleshoot the fire alarm system, the good multimeter is still in the truck.